It goes without saying that teachers play one of the most critical roles in American society as the primary individuals responsible, other than a young person’s parents, for helping to create the next generation of leaders and workers.
But that weighty responsibility rarely matches up with the highest salary. As a result, retirement planning requires additional foresight, planning, and better lifelong financial habits for teachers than for their white-collar counterparts working the 9 to 5 in a downtown corner office.
And on top of that, teachers often have more intricate possibilities for retirement because they can invest in pension accounts. The question for teachers becomes not only how much can I or should I invest, but also which mix of accounts will create the best opportunity for a satisfying retirement?
Let’s take a hard look at what teachers need to know about retirement planning. If you’re a teacher, you know that your financial security can be completely different than the teacher across the hall from you.
So, we are first going to understand the most popular types of retirement plans for teachers and how those can be combined with your other benefits like pension and Social Security.
Specifically, we’ll do a deep dive into a popular retirement account for teachers—the 403b account.
Once it’s all over, you should have a good understanding of the right way to plan for retirement and which methods might fit your situation.
Most Popular Types of Retirement Accounts Among Teachers
In the following section, we will identify and define the most popular retirement and investment accounts for professionals like yourself.
A 403b is a retirement plan available to educational and health care institutions, in addition to certain non-profit organizations (police, firefighters, churches, etc.). This type of account is named after the section of the IRS code governing it and grows tax deferred until you begin to withdrawal from it at retirement.
Certain employees of tax-exempt organizations are eligible to participate. Participants include, but are not limited to, doctors, professors, nurses, teachers, ministers and administrators. Like a 401k, employees must work through their employer to setup and participate in their plan. Although the options can vary, employees execute a salary reduction agreement to make pre-tax contributions.
These contributions are then sent to custodians chosen by the employer (such as Fidelity Investments). Contributions grow tax-deferred until the time of retirement, when withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.
A 403b also offers favorable contribution limits to investors. In 2018, those limits were $18,500 per individual. Combined with a “catch up” limit of $6,000 for anyone over the age of fifty, you could contribute up to $24,500 of your own money to a 403b plan. In 2019, the contribution limit is rising by $500 up to $19,000.
Plans that function similarly to a 403b but are named slightly different include: 401a and 457b plans.
According to a study done by the Spectrum Group over 70% of the assets in 403b plans are comprised of various types of annuities.
Annuities, in many cases, are complicated, inappropriate and not suitable for anyone except the product companies who are profiting off the people invested in those annuities.
When most people outside the educational sector think of retirement for teachers, many of them believe that all teachers receive a set pension, much like federal employees.
But as a teacher, you know that’s not necessarily true—the amount you might receive during retirement all depends on your school district and where you live. You may not even receive a pension at all.
In fact, even when pensions were more abundant in white-collar companies, they were still a small portion of a retiree’s income, totaling about 14% for the average person.
A pension is separate than a 403b in that a 403b is a defined contribution plan, where you add your own money to it and may receive an employer match. Then (at least theoretically) it’s time to let the stock market go to work to grow your assets.
A pension is different in that this type of account is known as a “defined benefit plan.” Your employer makes the contributions, and typically you receive a set amount upon your retirement, instead of a variable amount based on however your money has grown in your defined contribution plan.
And of course, that set amount depends on your salary, which differs wildly depending on the state in which you teach.
For comparison’s sake, if you’re a new retiree, in my home state of Florida, the average benefit is $19,765 while in Ohio it is $46,620.
Most secondary school teachers in American today—eighty-five percent according to a 2017 survey—participate in a defined-benefit pension plan.
Comparatively, only eight percent of teachers are enrolled in a defined-contribution plan like a 403b or a 401k account.
Social Security Benefits
Most Americans look at Social Security benefits as an important component in their quest to finance their retirements.
For most people, Social Security alone can’t carry a twenty-year retirement plan. But it’s even worse for many teachers, Social Security benefits are not even available for secondary school teachers in fifteen states.
If you live in a state where teachers aren’t covered by Social Security and your pension is your only retirement plan, you may need to think about adjusting your plan.
Let’s say you’re a teacher in Louisiana. The average pension amount for a new retiree is $25,836.00 — and you aren’t covered by Social Security benefits.
Recent studies have found that only about 60% of teachers can even pay into Social Security and receive benefits. If you don’t know if you are or are not covered by Social Security, the time to find out is right now.
Spending and Saving for Teachers: How Your Profession Impacts Your Retirement Strategy
As someone who works in education, you likely didn’t choose the profession to make a lot of green.
In most states, the average salary for teachers varies between $40,000-$80,000.
At the university level, the averages are closer to the higher end of the range but we also can’t forget that the higher your level of expertise in a given field, a higher level of debt likely comes with it from those years of education.
You got into your job because you wanted to positively impact young lives (a common refrain among secondary-level teachers) or because you’re an expert in your field and want to pass on that knowledge to others (a common refrain among university professors).
So, because high income is not necessarily going to be true for many teachers, it’s important that your retirement strategy includes a variety of techniques and considerations to help you more fully prepare for retirement.
Budgeting and Saving
If you listen to the talking heads on cable business channels, you’re likely to believe that successful retirement is all about jumping in on the hot stocks, putting all your money into things called “options”, “calls” or “puts” but it’s unlikely that any of those strategies are going to lead to you feeling more confident in having the money to retire, and they’re all more liable to give you a bad night’s sleep instead.
It’s not as sexy as unearthing the next great tech company, but much of retirement success comes down to your behaviors and habits.
This focus on financial habits is especially important in a field where earning power is limited and pay raises are tightly controlled and often dependent on years in service and your education level.
Here are three quick behavior tips:
- Build positive money habits - When you do get a raise, chunk up any additional money you get into buckets. It’s okay to spend some of it, but you must remain disciplined. Put some toward debt, some toward savings, and another amount can be for spending.
- Understand your limits - No one knows you better than yourself. If your income isn’t likely to rise above a certain threshold, then figure out ways to maximize your saving opportunities now before you reach the point of no return.
- Plan with realistic goals - Some of the satisfaction with your retirement will come down to personal expectations. Maybe your retirement won’t see you taking a trip to Hawaii every year—so what is a plan that is both realistic and will still make you happy? Set your sights on what you can achieve, and you’ll feel more fulfilled.
If any of this seems daunting then you may want to consider hiring a financial coach who can offer guidance.
Take Advantage of Employer Benefits
Sometimes employers will offer to match contributions to your account if you’re invested in a defined-contribution plan. And sometimes, those matching contributions are tied to how much you contribute yourself.
Let’s not beat around the bush—these types of employer benefits are huge for long-term success. Do whatever you can do to ensure that you are taking full advantage of benefits like this and getting all the benefits your employer owes you.
If you contribute 7% to your retirement account and your employer offers a 3% match, then you’re up to 10% of your income and over time that additional percentage will make a huge difference in your retirement portfolio.
The 403b for Teachers
Earlier in this write up we took a brief look at 403b accounts.
If you skipped that section, here’s a quick rundown:
What is it?
A retirement plan available to educational and health care institutions, in addition to certain non-profit organizations (police, firefighters, churches, etc.).
Who can use it?
Certain employees of tax-exempt organizations are eligible to participate. Participants include, but are not limited to, doctors, professors, nurses, teachers, ministers and administrators.
Why is it a good option?
Contribution limits are favorable. Earnings are tax-deferred.
With that out of the way, let’s look more in-depth at why this type of account can be a good option for you.
How Can a 403b Benefit Teachers
If your employer offers a 403b, you should absolutely take advantage of it.
Investing offers you a tremendous opportunity to put money you save to work for your future retirement needs. Think of it like getting a little extra money in your paycheck without having to work additional hours.
Instead, your money works for you behind the scenes while you continue to work, allowing you to reap the rewards later.
The money you earn today is worth more in the present than in the future because of inflation. This is a concept called the time value of money.
You can see a real-life example of this idea in the prices of many basic goods you purchase—for instance, a gallon of milk costs more today than it did 30 or 40 years ago and will likely cost more 30 or 40 years from now.
Inflation, as it is known, erodes the purchasing power of the money you save today so it won’t buy as much in the future. But you can counter the effects of inflation by seeking to grow your savings over time by investing it.
At the very least, you need to earn a return on your savings each year to match the annual inflation rate. That helps you break even by maintaining your money’s purchasing power.
Now, making your money work for you is something that can apply to any investment account, but 403b accounts offer a few major benefits over other types of investment accounts:
- Contribution limits are very favorable for you, they come from your pre-tax earnings up to the annual limit and are automatically deducted from your paycheck.
- Tax-deferred growth helps you keep and reinvest more of the money you earn on your investments, because any gains or earnings you realize on your investments won’t be taxed until you withdraw them. When tax-deferred growth and earnings stay in your 403b account, they can compound over time to help you accumulate greater wealth.
- You can gain access to several investment options from professional investment managers using pooled investment vehicles such as mutual funds.
All these benefits won’t be worth much to you, however, if you don’t personalize your investment approach in such a way that the risk you take correlates to the goals you want to achieve.
Understanding the Role of Risk for Your Retirement
People who work in finance have many ways to talk about risk and many of their terms don’t make much sense to the average investor—alpha, beta, Sharpe ratio and so on. At the end of the day, how much do you, or frankly most financial professionals, really understand about these terms?
The answer is: not much.
No one really understands risk, so investors don’t talk about it and the consequences are significant. Only one in four clients say their financial advisor has talked about how much their investments may decline if the market crashes.
And what if you don’t have a financial advisor at all?
It’s a good bet that most people aren’t even thinking about risk at all—taking that number down to zero out of four clients discussing risk.
People think about risk and reward trade-offs nearly every day, most often outside of the context of the investment markets.
Consider these choices:
- “Should I buy life insurance?” You weigh the risk of paying too much premium for a life policy, versus the reward of knowing your beneficiaries get some degree of financial protection.
- “What should my car insurance deductible be?” You may reward yourself with lower premiums by choosing a higher deductible, but you risk paying more out of pocket if you have an accident.
- “Should I go to the gym or stay on my couch?” You risk the poor health consequences of a sedentary lifestyle for the reward of easy entertainment.
Measuring and discussing investment risk needs to be kept simple. The one risk measurement you should care about the most (whether you realize it or not) is maximum drawdown risk—how much can you potentially lose in a catastrophic market downturn?
Click on the video below to see the benefits of tactical money management:
Remember, investing is a marathon, not a sprint.
It’s easy to get caught up in the latest hot stock, but the investors who survive and prosper are those who can manage their investment risk.
When It’s Time to Talk to a Professional
With all that being said, it’s not easy to plan for your retirement on your own.
Sure, there are many people who love the DIY aspect of investing. But between lesson plans, office hours, and that summer vacation (that, let’s be honest, isn’t much of a vacation at all)how much time do you have to put toward making sure your finances are matching up to give you the kind of retirement you want to have?
If you find yourself identifying with any of these four scenarios, then it’s time to talk to a professional:
- You aren’t comfortable with choosing your own funds - Did you open a 403b and just checked off a few boxes without understanding how those choices fit together for a cohesive plan? Maybe you are invested in a single target-date fund that matches up with your expected retirement date.
- A market downturn makes you scared/uncomfortable - Remember max drawdown in our risk section earlier? If you don’t know how much you can lose in your account and still feel comfortable with your finances, then you probably don’t have a solid plan in place for retirement at all.
- You often worry about your investments - You shouldn’t stay up at night worrying about how much you’ll have saved for retirement. You shouldn’t have your mind drifting off during class if you noticed during lunch that the markets are taking a sudden dip. If you worry a lot, it’s a sure sign that it’s time for a professional to step in to offer you guidance.
- You have complex questions that need answers – Complexity can be different for everyone. If you live in a state where you will receive Social Security benefits, and you have a Pension, it could be that you have questions about how both of those benefits will work together to provide you with a retirement that aligns with your goals in life.
See yourself in one of these four situations? We’re here to help.
A Little About Potomac Fund Management
Potomac Fund Management is an SEC registered fee-only investment advisor. Our team of professionals shares three core beliefs:
- Small businesses form the strength of the economy.
- Technology, when used correctly, should enhance our lives—not take it over.
- Relationships and customer service still matter, and not everything has to be delivered with a ticket number.
As a fiduciary and fee-only advisor, we sit on your side of the table to educate and deliver risk-managed investment strategies specific to your situation. We don’t believe in or sell complicated commission-laden investment products.
We put our money where our mouth is and invest our own personal assets in the same strategies, we recommend to you.